Susan B. Anthony and the women who organized with her saw a specific legal problem: American women were taxed, tried, and governed without any vote in making the laws that bound them, and in most states married women's earnings and property belonged to their husbands. They did about it what the law allowed β€” petitions, lobbying, annual conventions, a newspaper, and, from 1868 onward, a sustained push for a federal amendment β€” and Anthony personally voted illegally in 1872 to force a test case. The change they wanted wasn't abstract goodwill; it was the ballot, married women's property rights, equal pay for equal work, and eventually an amendment to the U.S. Constitution. This article covers all three questions the keyword asks β€” problem, method, goal β€” state by state and year by year.

The plainest statement of the problem comes from Anthony's own 1872–73 court case. After she voted in Rochester, New York, she was arrested, indicted, and tried for "knowingly, wrongfully and unlawfully" voting "without having a lawful right to vote." That indictment is the problem in one sentence: the law forbade her from voting.

The grievance had two halves. The first was political. Women paid taxes, were subject to criminal law, and were counted in the census for apportioning Congress, but had no ballot to remove a bad officeholder. Anthony made this argument in her 1873 speech "Is It a Crime for a Citizen of the United States to Vote?" delivered across Monroe County before her trial.

The second half was economic and marital. Under the doctrine of coverture inherited from English common law, a married woman had no separate legal identity: wages, inherited property, and even her children belonged to her husband. New York's Married Women's Property Act of 1860, which Anthony had lobbied for, was a partial fix, not a full one.

A third problem was institutional. Before 1920, voting rules were set state by state. Wyoming Territory let women vote in 1869; New York did not. So a woman's rights depended entirely on which border she happened to live inside β€” a fact that shaped the entire strategy described in the sections below.

Reading the 1873 indictment: the exact charge Anthony faced

The charge against Anthony was not disorderly conduct or trespass. According to the federal court record in United States v. Susan B. Anthony (Circuit Court for the Northern District of New York, 1873), she was accused of voting "without having a lawful right to vote" and of doing so knowingly, which the prosecution framed as a federal crime under enforcement acts passed after the Civil War.

The legal theory Anthony and her attorney Henry Selden used was constitutional, not procedural. They argued that the Fourteenth Amendment's first section made her a citizen of the United States, and that the privileges or immunities of citizenship included the franchise. The court rejected that reading; Justice Ward Hunt directed the jury to return a guilty verdict before the defense had even presented its case.

That ruling mattered beyond Anthony. It effectively told every woman in the country that the Fourteenth Amendment's guarantee of citizenship did not carry the vote with it. Her fine β€” $100 plus costs β€” was never collected, but the legal door was slammed shut, which pushed the movement toward a separate amendment.

From Seneca Falls to the ballot box: what they actually did

Anthony's methods were the legitimate tools of nineteenth-century politics, used relentlessly. She did not have a vote, but she had a printing press, an address book, and a talent for organizing that few contemporaries matched.

Her sequence of action ran roughly like this:

1: Petition. Anthony served as an officer of the American Anti-Slavery Society and later the National Woman Suffrage Association, and helped circulate petitions to state legislatures and Congress. 2: Build organizations. She co-founded the American Equal Rights Association in 1866 with Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Frederick Douglass, then the National Woman Suffrage Association in 1869 after the AERA split over the Fifteenth Amendment. 3: Publish. Starting in 1868, she and Stanton ran The Revolution, a weekly paper in New York that covered suffrage, equal pay, and divorce law. 4: Convene. Annual conventions in Washington, D.C., kept the demand visible to Congress year after year, even when it went nowhere. 5: Test the law. In November 1872 she registered and voted in Rochester, was arrested, and used the trial as a public platform. 6: Lobby for state action. She traveled the country campaigning on state referenda, including Kansas in 1867. 7: Collect the record. With Stanton and Matilda Joslyn Gage she compiled the six-volume History of Woman Suffrage, begun in the 1870s, which preserved the movement's paper trail.

Notice what is missing from that list: there was no armed confrontation and no attempt to seize power. The strategy assumed that steady, documented pressure would eventually change the law.

1872: the vote that produced an arrest and a national argument

On November 5, 1872, Anthony and about fourteen other Rochester women registered and voted in the presidential election. Registrars accepted them; a poll watcher later swore out a complaint against Anthony. She was arrested at home, and β€” according to accounts in her own letters and the History of Woman Suffrage β€” she refused to pay bail to avoid arrest, forcing the authorities to carry the arrest forward.

She then took the argument on the road. Before the trial, she spoke in towns across Monroe County on the question of whether a citizen's right to vote existed regardless of sex. The trial itself began in Canandaigua, New York, in June 1873.

The result was a conviction with a fine and no jail sentence, a design that denied her any route to appeal. That detail β€” no imprisonment means no appeal β€” is often left out of the popular version. It meant the legal loss was total and the political gain had to come from publicity, which it did.

What the movement wanted: the ballot as the door to everything else

The demand was not vague "equality." Anthony's generation wanted a list of specific legal changes, and the vote was the tool to get them.

Goal What it meant in practice Where it stood in Anthony's lifetime
Woman suffrage Full voting rights in state and federal elections Wyoming Territory granted it in 1869; through the 1800s, roughly a hundred state referenda campaigns came and went
Married women's property Wages, inheritance, and custody retained after marriage New York's 1860 act gave partial rights; Anthony lobbied for passage
Equal pay for equal work The same wage for the same job Anthony helped organize working women and demanded pay parity; the movement used this slogan long before federal law existed
Access to education and professions Colleges and trades open to women Progress was uneven; the first women's colleges and coeducational state universities appeared in this era
A federal constitutional amendment A rule that no state could deny the vote for sex Proposed in the 1870s, introduced in Congress repeatedly, and passed as the Nineteenth Amendment in 1919–20 β€” fourteen years after Anthony died in 1906

The table is the key to the whole story. Anthony did not live to see the amendment pass. She saw incremental state victories and a lengthening pile of defeats, which is why her later strategy focused on building an endowment and a trained national staff she called her "lieutenants."

What they did about it, state by state: the referenda record

Because voting rules were state law, the movement's practical work was a grind of state campaigns. The pattern was consistent: organize a committee, petition the legislature, force a referendum, then fight hostile press, liquor lobby opposition, and party machines that saw women's votes as a threat to their coalition.

Results were mixed and local. Wyoming Territory allowed women to vote in 1869 and kept the right when it became a state in 1890. Colorado granted full suffrage by referendum in 1893, followed by Utah and Idaho in 1896. But in New York, a 1894 constitutional referendum went down; the state did not grant full suffrage until 1917. Kansas rejected suffrage by referendum in 1867 β€” the campaign Anthony worked personally β€” and didn't grant presidential suffrage until 1912.

The failure cases are the ones that tell you how the machine worked. When the WCTU weighted in, suffrage organizers feared it would tar the movement with temperance. When it stayed out, they lacked troops. This made early referenda expensive, slow, and sometimes self-defeating β€” a cost that explains the shift after 1900 toward the national amendment strategy.

Equal pay, divorce, and property: the laws behind the slogan

Anthony's argument on wages was both political and economic: women who own their wages are harder to cheat, and women who can vote are harder to underpay. The History of Woman Suffrage records her repeated insistence that "equal pay for equal work" was not a courtesy but a rule of justice, and she pressed the case while working alongside women in trades and factories.

The property issue was concrete. Until state married women's property laws were passed, a husband could collect his wife's wages. New York's 1860 Married Women's Property Act helped, but it was followed by years of legal chipping from judges who read its limits narrowly. Anthony and her allies understood that constitutional protection was the only fix that couldn't be undone by a single court ruling or a single hostile legislature.

Divorce law was the messiest of the three. Stanton wanted liberal divorce, and Anthony did not push it with the same enthusiasm β€” she judged it political poison for the suffrage referendum in the moment. The split is worth noting because it shows the movement made trade-offs, not pure principle. That calculation was probably correct in the short term and costly in the long term, since it left women's marital status entangled with their civil status for generations.

The failures they faced β€” and what those failures changed

The clearest failure was constitutional. In Minor v. Happersett (1875), the Supreme Court ruled that citizenship did not automatically confer the right to vote β€” a decision arising from a Missouri woman's attempt to vote in 1872, closely related in spirit to Anthony's own case. That ruling settled the question for the movement: a separate amendment was now mandatory.

The second failure was organizational. The 1869 split over the Fifteenth Amendment β€” whether to support a voting-rights amendment that enfranchised Black men but not women β€” fractured the movement for twenty years. The Association soon had two wings, the NWSA in New York and the American Woman Suffrage Association in Boston, and they did not merge until 1890 as the National American Woman Suffrage Association.

The third failure was generational. By the time Anthony died in 1906, four states had full suffrage for women. When the Nineteenth Amendment passed in 1919 and was ratified on August 26, 1920, it needed a coalition built by successors like Carrie Chapman Catt and the newer congressional-union strategy led by Alice Paul's National Woman's Party. Anthony's methods made that coalition possible; she did not see the finish.

FAQ

Did Susan B. Anthony's case get her out of paying her fine?

No. She refused to pay it, and the court imposed no jail sentence, so she was never forced to pay. The fine of $100 plus costs stood as a bookkeeping entry. Because there was no imprisonment, her legal team had no ruling to appeal β€” which is why the conviction became a public argument rather than a legal precedent.

Was the goal always a federal constitutional amendment?

No. In the 1860s and 1870s, the movement put most of its effort into state referenda, because voting rules were state law and a win in one state was immediately visible. The shift to a federal amendment became dominant after the Supreme Court's Minor v. Happersett decision in 1875 closed the citizenship route and after decades of expensive state campaigns produced only a handful of wins.

Did Black women and Black men support woman suffrage in this period?

Many did, and the historical record shows both alliance and tension. Frederick Douglass co-founded the American Equal Rights Association with Anthony and Stanton in 1866, and Black suffragists campaigned for the Nineteenth Amendment alongside white organizers. The Fifteenth Amendment split, though, set a lasting pattern in which white suffrage leaders sometimes prioritized their own enfranchisement over Black voting rights.

What did Anthony actually mean by "equal pay for equal work"?

She meant the same wage for the same job regardless of sex, and she argued it publicly while organizing working women. She lived long before any federal equal-pay statute existed, so the demand was moral and political pressure, not a legal claim she could file. Modern equal-pay law came much later and rests on different legal foundations.

How many states had full woman suffrage when Anthony died?

Four β€” Wyoming, Colorado, Utah, and Idaho. Wyoming allowed women to vote from 1869 and kept the right through statehood in 1890; Colorado granted full suffrage in 1893; Utah and Idaho followed in 1896. That count of four, reached after more than a century of organizing, is the most direct measure of how slow the state-by-state route was.

Did she ever get to vote again legally?

No. She was convicted in 1873 and never received a pardon or a restoration of voting rights in her lifetime. The Nineteenth Amendment, ratified in August 1920, was fourteen years after her death. Her only actual ballot was the illegal one cast in Rochester in November 1872.

Is the "taxation without representation" slogan accurate to her time?

Yes as an argument, not as a legal claim. Women did pay taxes and were subject to the law, and they had no vote. But the Supreme Court in Minor v. Happersett made clear that citizenship plus taxation still didn't produce a franchise in American constitutional law. That gap, not a lack of merit in the slogan, is why the amendment became necessary.