The Romans took control of Judea from the Hebrews, and the decisive loss of the land came with the destruction of Jerusalem and the Second Temple in 70 CE under the general Titus. The Egyptians, Persians, and Armenians each ruled or invaded the region at other points, but none of them permanently stripped the Hebrews of Judea. The Persians actually restored the Jews to the land after the Babylonian exile, which makes them the wrong answer in the opposite direction from what most quiz-takers assume.

This is a question that gets asked in two different ways. Sometimes it's a multiple-choice test item, and the reader wants the single box to tick. Other times it's a genuine history question, and the reader wants to know why Rome rather than one of the other four names is the answer, and what "took control away" actually means when a people had already been conquered several times before. Both readings get answered here, and the distinction between ruling the land and removing the people from it matters more than most short explanations admit.

Why the Romans are the answer, and the exact point of loss

The Roman takeover didn't happen in a single afternoon. Judea became a Roman client kingdom in 63 BCE when Pompey intervened in a Hasmonean civil war and entered Jerusalem, and it became a directly administered province in 6 CE after Herod Archelaus was deposed. The event that most historians treat as the break is the First Jewish–Roman War, which ran from 66 to 73 CE and ended with the Temple destroyed and the last holdouts at Masada in 73 CE.

The Temple fell in August of 70 CE, and the date is locked down by the Roman historian Josephus, who wrote as an eyewitness-turned-advocate and dated the burning to the same month the Babylonians had destroyed the First Temple centuries earlier. Josephus puts the total dead across the war in the tens of thousands, and ancient casualty figures from any source should be read as orders of magnitude rather than counts. What is not in dispute is the institutional outcome: the sacrificial system ended, the high priesthood ended, and the Sanhedrin's authority was broken.

"Control of the land" then passed through Roman hands to a series of successor administrations. A second revolt under Bar Kokhba, in 132 to 135 CE, was crushed by Hadrian, and after it the province was renamed Syria Palaestina, a deliberate renaming tied to the defeated rebels. That renaming is the strongest single piece of evidence that Rome was the power that took the land away in a durable, legal, administrative sense, because renaming a province is what you do when you want the old name and its claims to stop existing.

So the answer to the multiple-choice item is the Romans, full stop. The other three names are either earlier conquerors of the region, temporary occupiers, or powers that never held Judea as a province at all. The rest of this article takes each one in turn and shows exactly where it sits on the timeline, because the wrong answers are more interesting than the right one.

Egypt: a pharaoh who marched through, not a ruler who stayed

Egypt appears in the Jewish story most prominently as the place of slavery and the Exodus, which is the national origin story rather than a conquest of Judea. In the historical period that concerns this question, the relevant Egyptian ruler is Pharaoh Shishak, usually identified with Sheshonq I of the 22nd Dynasty, who campaigned into the Levant around 925 BCE and is named in 1 Kings and 2 Chronicles.

Shishak's campaign is recorded on the walls of the Temple of Karnak at Thebes, where the pharaoh's scribes carved a list of captured towns. The list is the kind of document that records every place a raiding column touched, not a settled administrative map. Egypt extracted tribute, took booty, and went home. There's no evidence of a lasting Egyptian provincial government in Judea after that campaign, and Jerusalem wasn't occupied long-term.

A later Egyptian dynasty, the Ptolemies, did control Judea for roughly a century after Alexander the Great's death, from about 301 to 200 BCE. That's a real Egyptian-ruled period, and it's the one point where the Egyptian answer has any legs at all. The Ptolemies were Greek-speaking Macedonians ruling from Alexandria, though, so calling them "the Egyptians" flattens a distinction that ancient sources cared about enormously.

The Ptolemies lost Judea to the Seleucid king Antiochus III at the Battle of Panium in 200 BCE. If the test question is about who held the land before the Romans, the honest answer is the Seleucids, then a brief period of Jewish independence under the Hasmoneans from the mid-160s BCE to 63 BCE, then Rome. Egypt is a real historical neighbor and overlord, but it never took the land away permanently and never governed it as an imperial province.

Persia: the empire that sent the Jews back, which is why it can't be the answer

Here's the trap. The Persians are famous in Jewish history for the opposite of dispossession. Cyrus the Great conquered Babylon in 539 BCE and issued a decree allowing the exiled Judeans to return to Jerusalem and rebuild the Temple, a policy recounted in the books of Ezra, Nehemiah, and Chronicles, and corroborated outside the Bible by the Cyrus Cylinder held in the British Museum, which records a general policy of returning captive peoples and their gods to their shrines.

The Second Temple was completed around 516 BCE, roughly seventy years after the First Temple fell to Babylon in 586 BCE. Persian rule over the province of Yehud lasted until Alexander's conquest in the 330s BCE. During that stretch the Persians were the imperial authority, not a foreign displacer. They taxed the province, appointed or recognized its governors, and generally let local religious life run.

The Persian period does have an internal crisis in the story of Esther, set at the court of Ahasuerus, usually identified with Xerxes I, where a vizier named Haman plots to destroy the Jews of the empire. The plot fails and the festival of Purim commemorates it. That's a court intrigue and a near-miss, not a conquest of the land of Judea, and it doesn't come close to the dispossession question.

If a quiz puts Persia on a list with Rome and asks who took the land away, the question is testing whether the student knows that the Persians are on the restoration side of the ledger. Cyrus is the only non-Jewish ruler in the Hebrew Bible called a messiah by name, in Isaiah 45, a fact that ought to end any confusion about Persia's role. Persia is the friendly empire in this story, which is exactly why it's a distractor.

Armenia: the answer that doesn't fit the timeline at all

Armenia is the strangest name on the list, and it's there because Armenia's own national history includes a period of Jewish significance: the Kingdom of Armenia adopted Christianity around 301 CE under King Tiridates III, making it the first state to do so. Armenia also had a large Jewish population in antiquity, and Armenian forces were involved in the border wars between Rome and Parthia over the region.

The most likely source of confusion is the activities of the Armenian king Tigranes the Great, who briefly built an empire that reached into Syria and the Levant around 83 to 69 BCE. Tigranes took over Seleucid Syria, and Judea was in Hasmonean hands at that moment, not Armenian ones. The Roman general Lucullus defeated Tigranes in 69 BCE and Pompey finished the job, which cleared the path for Pompey's own intervention in Judea six years later. So Armenia is adjacent to the story, at the same moment in the first century BCE, but never held Jerusalem.

An even more likely reason Armenia shows up is that it's a predominantly Christian nation with a long and often tragic history, and it doesn't take much for a quiz-writer looking for plausible-sounding ancient empires to add it to a list. The name looks right if you don't know the timeline. If you do know the timeline, Armenia is easy to eliminate because it has no conquest of Judea to point to, and the burden of proof sits entirely on whoever put it on the list.

The power that actually did precede Rome: Babylon, oddly missing

The name that should be on the list and isn't is Babylon. Nebuchadnezzar II besieged Jerusalem twice, took it in 597 BCE, and destroyed the First Temple in 586 BCE, deporting a large portion of the population. That is the original dispossession, the one that gives the whole question its shape, and it predates Rome by more than six centuries. If the test were asking who first took the land from the Hebrews in the era of the monarchy, Babylon is the answer and Rome is the sequel.

The reason the question is usually framed around Rome is that Rome's conquest ended the political independence of Judea in a way that proved irreversible for most of the next two millennia. Babylon's exile ended after about seventy years. Rome's did not. That's the distinction the question is reaching for, and it's the reason the Romans are the "correct" answer even though Babylon and several other empires got there first.

There's also a meaningful gap between the Babylonians and the Romans. After the exile, Judea was a Persian province, then a Ptolemaic and then a Seleucid one, then briefly independent under the Hasmoneans. The Hasmoneans were the last native Jewish dynasty to rule the land, and when Pompey took Jerusalem in 63 BCE, he walked into the Temple's Holy of Holies, an act of contempt that Josephus records and that set the tone for everything that followed. The question is really asking when the last native dynasty fell, and the answer is Rome.

How to read a multiple-choice version of this question without losing points

If you're answering this in a test, the logic is a process of elimination that takes about fifteen seconds, and it's worth doing in that order rather than trying to recall the whole history. The method below is the same one you'd use for any ancient-history multiple-choice item where one answer feels obviously modern or obviously friendly.

1: Eliminate any option that never held Jerusalem as a territory. Armenia goes first, for the reasons above. 2: Eliminate any option whose main historical role was to restore rather than dispossess. Persia goes second, because of Cyrus. 3: Eliminate any option whose contact with the region was a raid or a short-lived dynasty. Egypt goes third, with the Ptolemaic caveat noted. 4: The remaining name is the one that held the land as a province, crushed the revolts, and renamed the province after the rebellion. That's Rome.

The failure case to watch for is a test that groups "Egyptians, Romans, Persians, Armenians" and asks which one toppled the Hasmonean dynasty directly. The answer is still Rome, because Pompey's intervention in 63 BCE ended the Hasmonean monarchy as an independent force, though the dynasty limped on as Roman clients until the Herodian line took over. A second failure case is a question phrased as "who destroyed the Temple," where the answer is also Rome but specifically the legions under Titus, with the caveat that Josephus says Titus wanted the Temple spared and the soldiers burned it anyway. That's a genuine dispute in the ancient source, and a careful student can note it without losing the point.

What "took control" actually means in this period, and why the wording matters

"Control of the land" is doing a lot of work in this question, and the concept was different from ownership. Empires in the ancient Near East controlled land through tribute relationships, military garrisons, appointed governors, and tax collection, and a province could change hands without a single farmer in the field noticing for a year. That's why Judea can have four or five imperial masters in six centuries without the population being moved anywhere.

Rome's control was more thorough than the earlier empires, and that's a real historical difference rather than a technicality. Rome annexed Judea as a province under a governor with a small standing garrison, conducted a census for taxation, and after 70 CE kept a legion based in Jerusalem. The Roman administration also conducted a post-war land survey and redistributed some Jewish-owned land to non-Jewish settlers in the region, a process that Josephus and later rabbinic sources both gesture toward, though the scale is debated.

The land itself did not empty out. The idea that the Jews were entirely expelled from Judea after 70 CE is a common overstatement, and it's the misconception worth flagging most firmly. There were later revolts, substantial Jewish communities continued in the Galilee and the coastal cities, and the migration to the Diaspora was a centuries-long process driven by economics and persecution as much as by any single expulsion order. The Romans took control of the land as a political fact. They did not clear it of its population in a single act.

Intact sources disagree on scale even when they agree on the event

The event itself isn't seriously disputed, which is unusual for ancient history. Josephus gives detailed numbers, the Roman historian Cassius Dio gives tallies for the revolt under Hadrian, and rabbinic literature preserves the trauma from the other side. The numbers differ wildly, and that's the honest picture.

Source Event Figure given Nature of the figure
Josephus, Jewish War Dead in the siege of Jerusalem, 70 CE 1,100,000 Aggregate of the whole war's dead, from a participant with a rhetorical purpose
Josephus, Jewish War Captives taken 97,000 Same source, same purpose, likely rounded
Cassius Dio, Roman History Roman losses in the Bar Kokhba revolt, 132–135 CE 580,000 killed on the Jewish side, 50 fortified towns, 985 villages Province-wide total, written a century later
Rabbinic tradition (Mishnah, Taanit) Bar Kokhba's fall at Betar No casualty count Focused on the date and the mourning, not the numbers

The table is useful mostly because it shows where the numbers come from and how much weight they can bear. Josephus was a client of the Flavians and had every incentive to inflate the scale of the victory while also humanizing the disaster; the figure of 1.1 million dead would exceed any plausible population of the Jerusalem area in the first century, so it's usually read as a literary number rather than a headcount. Cassius Dio's 580,000 is closer to usable but still sits in the same category.

The practical lesson is that the event dates are reliable and the body counts are not. If you're writing about this, cite the year and the outcome, and if you cite a casualty figure, name the source and say it's contested. The dates that hold: Temple destroyed 70 CE, Masada 73 CE, Bar Kokhba 132–135 CE, province renamed Syria Palaestina after 135 CE.

What happened to the land and the people after 135 CE

After the Bar Kokhba revolt, the Romans took the harsher steps, and the archaeological record is clearer than the literary one for what followed. Jewish settlement contracts in the hill country of Judea, but it doesn't disappear; the Galilee becomes the demographic and scholarly center of Jewish life, and the Mishnah is compiled there around 200 CE under Judah ha-Nasi, which is a sign of a functioning, self-governing community rather than a scattered remnant.

The province's renaming to Syria Palaestina, the merging of it with the neighboring province, and the founding of a Roman colony at Jerusalem called Aelia Capitolina after the revolt are all administrative markers of Rome's intent to refound the region on its own terms. Hadrian's colony is the one that most directly indicates that Rome was not merely ruling the land but reassigning its identity.

By the time Rome itself became Christian in the fourth century, the land's character had changed for good, with a substantial non-Jewish population, a Christian holy-land tradition, and a Jewish minority that still lived there. The "took control away" framing can obscure the fact that the population never entirely left, and that the next several centuries were a story of slow demographic and religious change rather than a single catastrophic emptying.

FAQ

Did the Romans take Judea in 63 BCE or 70 CE?

Both dates mark real transfers, and they answer different questions. In 63 BCE, Pompey entered Jerusalem and brought the Hasmonean state under Roman power as a client kingdom. In 70 CE, the Temple was destroyed and the province was directly governed by Rome, which is the point most historians name when they ask when Judea was "lost." For a multiple-choice item, 70 CE is the standard answer.

Was it really the Egyptians who enslaved the Hebrews?

Not in the sense of an empire that later took the land of Judea. The enslavement story is the Exodus narrative, set in Egypt and commemorated in the Passover, and it belongs to the origin story rather than the imperial timeline. The Egyptian contact that shows up in the historical record is Shishak's campaign around 925 BCE, which was a tribute raid, not a conquest and occupation.

Why is Persia on the list when Cyrus helped the Jews?

That's precisely why Persia is a distractor. Cyrus the Great allowed the exiles to return and rebuild the Temple after 539 BCE, and the period of Persian rule over Yehud is the restoration period rather than a dispossession. A test that includes Persia is checking whether you know the difference between the empire that uprooted the population and the one that let it come back.

Could the answer be "the Babylonians"?

The Babylonians did it first. Nebuchadnezzar II took Jerusalem in 597 BCE and destroyed the First Temple in 586 BCE, which is the original exile. If the question says "took control away" in the sense of a lasting dispossession, Rome is the conventional answer because the post-70 CE loss never reversed, while the Babylonian exile ended after about seventy years under Cyrus.

Who ruled Judea between Babylon and Rome?

A sequence: the Persians from 539 BCE until Alexander's conquest in the 330s BCE, the Ptolemies of Egypt until roughly 200 BCE, the Seleucids until the Hasmonean revolt in the mid-160s BCE, and then the independent Hasmonean dynasty until Pompey entered Jerusalem in 63 BCE. That four-century stretch is why "the land changed hands several times" is the accurate answer, and why the Roman conquest wasn't the first.

What happened to the Temple, and was Titus responsible?

The Second Temple was destroyed in August of 70 CE during the Roman siege, and Josephus says Titus wanted it spared while the legions torched it in the chaos of the assault. Whether that claim is sincere is debated, since Josephus wrote under Flavian patronage. The outcome is undisputed: the sacrificial system ended and the Temple has never been rebuilt.

Did the Romans expel the entire Jewish population from Judea?

No. That's the misconception worth correcting most firmly, because it drives a lot of confused claims about the region. There were deportations, land confiscations, and severe reprisals, but substantial Jewish communities remained in the Galilee and elsewhere, and the rabbinic academies that produced the Mishnah and the Talmud flourished inside the land, not outside it. The Diaspora grew for centuries through multiple causes.

What is the difference between Judea and Syria Palaestina?

They're names for the same general region under different administrations. Judea was the Roman province that came out of the Jewish state, and after the Bar Kokhba revolt of 132–135 CE, Hadrian merged and renamed it Syria Palaestina. The renaming is usually read as a deliberate act of deleting the province's Jewish identity in the wake of the revolt, though the precise motivation is an inference from the timing rather than a surviving imperial memo.

This article is general educational information about ancient history and is not legal, political, or religious advice. Historical dates and names follow Josephus, Cassius Dio, and the archaeological record, and where those disagree, the article says so. For any question with present-day legal or political stakes, consult a qualified local professional or the relevant public authority.