The fixation device most often left in the body after a fracture heals is the orthopedic bone plate and its screws, followed closely by intramedullary nails and cannulated screws. In practice, most fracture hardware stays in permanently unless it causes symptoms, because removal requires a second surgery and carries its own risks. The device type matters less than whether it's symptomatic.
Most people asking this question have a plate or nail already inside them and want to know if it's normal to keep it. It is. Hardware retention is the default in adult fracture care across the United States and most of Europe, and removal is the exception, not the rule.
Why Bone Plates and Screws Are the Most Commonly Retained Devices
Plates and screws account for the largest share of implanted fracture hardware worldwide. A plate is a metal strip fixed to the bone surface with screws, bridging a fracture or holding fragments in alignment while callus forms. Surgeons use them on the wrist, ankle, forearm, clavicle, and jaw β all high-volume fracture sites.
The reason plates stay in is straightforward: once bone union is confirmed, the plate is no longer load-bearing in a meaningful way, but removing it means reopening the surgical site, risking infection, and exposing the bone to a second round of healing. The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons has stated that routine removal of hardware is not medically necessary in most cases. Surgeons weigh that against a small but real complication rate for explantation surgery.
Plates also sit close to the skin on the distal radius and ankle, which makes them noticeable. A patient may feel the plate edge under thin skin or report cold sensitivity over the metal. Those symptoms drive most removal requests, not the mere presence of the device.
In the United States, plate fixation for distal radius fractures alone runs into the hundreds of thousands of procedures annually based on orthopedic registry data, making plates the single largest category of retained hardware by volume even if nails get more attention in hip and femur discussions.
Intramedullary Nails: Long-Bone Hardware That Almost Always Stays
An intramedullary nail is a metal rod inserted down the canal of a long bone β typically the femur or tibia β with locking screws at each end. Nails are the standard fixation for femoral shaft fractures and many tibial shaft fractures. They're also common after hip fracture surgery in the form of cephalomedullary nails, which combine a nail with a screw into the femoral head.
Nails are rarely removed. Pulling a femoral nail means re-entering the canal, and the procedure has a higher complication profile than plate removal because of the bone's central canal and the locking screws that may have bony overgrowth. Most orthopedic surgeons tell patients the nail can stay for life.
The one common exception involves young patients. A skeletally immature child or adolescent with a nail across an open growth plate may need removal to avoid growth disturbance, but that's a pediatric decision made case by case. In adults, the nail is a permanent resident unless infection or hardware failure forces revision.
Locking screws at the end of a nail occasionally back out or cause irritation at the knee or hip. When that happens, a surgeon may remove just the offending screw rather than the whole nail, which is a smaller operation than full explantation.
Screws Alone and the Smallest Retained Implants
Cannulated screws β hollow screws threaded over a guidewire β are used for femoral neck fractures, scaphoid fractures, and some ankle fractures. They're small, buried deep, and almost never removed unless they migrate or the fracture fails to heal. A patient with three screws in a healed femoral neck typically carries them for decades without issue.
Small fragment screws, Kirschner wires (K-wires), and tension band constructs fall into the same category. K-wires are often left protruding through the skin temporarily and removed in clinic after a few weeks, which makes them the exception: many K-wires are designed to come out. But buried screws and small plates stay.
The rule of thumb orthopedic surgeons use: the smaller and deeper the implant, the less likely anyone touches it again. Small hardware rarely causes symptoms, and removing it means a surgery with no functional gain.
The Removal Decision: When Surgeons Actually Take Hardware Out
Removal is a clinical decision, not a routine one. The table below lays out the categories surgeons use when advising patients.
| Scenario | Typical decision | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Asymptomatic healed fracture, adult | Leave in place | No benefit from removal; second surgery risk |
| Plate prominent under skin, pain with pressure | Offer removal after union confirmed | Symptom relief is the main indication |
| Hardware infection or loosening | Remove or revise | Device is failing or causing harm |
| Pediatric hardware crossing growth plate | Often remove | Growth disturbance risk |
| K-wire protruding through skin | Remove in clinic | Designed for removal |
| Hardware blocking future surgery (e.g., joint replacement) | Sometimes remove | Planning for later procedure |
| Patient request without symptoms | Surgeon discretion, usually declined | Risks outweigh benefits |
The general guideline from orthopedic societies is that hardware removal should be considered when the device causes symptoms, interferes with function, or poses a risk β not simply because the fracture has healed. A 2019 review in the Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research noted that removal rates vary widely by country, with some European centers removing far more hardware than U.S. centers for cultural and patient-preference reasons rather than clinical ones.
Age matters. Younger patients are more likely to request removal because they have decades of potential irritation ahead. Older patients usually decline once they understand the surgery involved.
What Removal Surgery Actually Involves and Costs
Removal is a real operation. It requires anesthesia, an incision over the hardware, dissection through scar tissue, and often a period of protected weight-bearing afterward. Scar tissue binds to implants, and screws can seize in bone, which occasionally forces the surgeon to leave a stuck screw in place.
Recovery from removal is shorter than from the original fracture fixation but not trivial. Most patients return to normal activity within a few weeks, and the bone temporarily has small screw holes that slightly weaken it β a reason surgeons advise against heavy loading right after explantation.
Cost is the argument most patients underweight. In the United States, hardware removal for a forearm plate commonly runs several thousand dollars in facility and surgeon fees, and even with insurance a patient may face meaningful out-of-pocket costs. For a device causing no symptoms, that's a poor trade. Patients should confirm coverage with their insurer before scheduling, because removal for "discomfort" is sometimes treated as elective.
There's also a failure case worth naming: some patients who have hardware removed report the pain doesn't go away. If the original pain came from the fracture site or soft tissue rather than the implant, removing the plate changes nothing. Surgeons counsel patients that symptom relief after removal is likely but not guaranteed.
Children, Growth Plates, and the Pediatric Exception
Pediatric fracture care uses hardware differently. A child's bones remodel aggressively, and hardware that spans an open growth plate can restrict growth if left too long. Pediatric orthopedic surgeons therefore plan removal more often than adult surgeons do, typically once union is solid and before the hardware can tether the physis.
Flexible nails used in pediatric forearm and femur fractures are commonly removed after healing, usually within a year or two. The procedure is smaller than adult explantation, and children recover quickly.
The distinction patients should hold onto: in children, removal is often part of the treatment plan from the start. In adults, it's an exception triggered by symptoms. Confusing the two leads adults to expect removal they don't need.
How Long Hardware Can Safely Stay In β and What Can Go Wrong
Orthopedic implants are designed to remain indefinitely. Titanium and stainless steel plates, nails, and screws tolerate decades in the body, and there's no expiration date after which hardware must come out. Surveillance data on retained implants shows most cause no problem for the patient's lifetime.
The failure scenarios are specific. Infection around hardware can smolder for years and may only surface after a dental procedure or a distant infection spreads to the implant. Loosening β where a screw backs out or a plate lifts β produces pain and occasionally visible deformity. Metal allergy is real but rare, and it's usually diagnosed after a reaction rather than predicted beforehand.
One edge case deserves attention: hardware near a joint can make later joint replacement harder. A surgeon planning a knee or hip replacement may want old plates or screws removed first to avoid contaminating the new implant field. That's a reason hardware sometimes comes out decades after the fracture healed, prompted by an unrelated operation.
Patients with retained hardware should tell any dentist or surgeon about it before procedures, since some guidelines recommend prophylactic antibiotics before dental work in the first two years after certain joint implants β though guidance on fracture hardware specifically is less uniform and worth confirming with the treating surgeon.
Titanium, Stainless Steel, and Why Material Rarely Drives Removal
Implant material affects MRI compatibility, allergy risk, and how the device integrates with bone. Titanium is more MRI-friendly and less likely to cause allergic reaction; stainless steel is stronger and cheaper. Neither material determines whether hardware comes out.
What does drive the decision: location, size, and symptoms. A titanium plate on the ankle that rubs against a boot gets removed more often than a stainless steel screw buried in a femoral neck. Material is a surgeon's choice at implantation, not a patient's reason for explantation.
Patients who need an MRI later should ask about their implant's MRI safety profile. Most modern fracture hardware is MRI-conditional, meaning it can be scanned under specified conditions, but the radiologist needs to know the device model. That information is in the operative report, which patients should keep.
The Countries Where Removal Is Routine β and Where It Isn't
Removal practice varies sharply by region. In parts of Germany, Austria, and Switzerland, patients often expect hardware removal as a standard follow-up, and some clinics schedule it routinely after tibial and ankle fractures. In the United States, the default runs the other way, with removal reserved for problems.
That difference is cultural and financial as much as medical. European systems with different reimbursement structures and patient expectations make removal a normal part of the pathway. U.S. surgeons, facing higher procedure costs and a strong evidence base that routine removal offers no benefit, generally advise against it.
For a patient moving between systems, the practical takeaway is to ask the treating surgeon in that country what the local norm is rather than assuming the advice they received elsewhere applies.
Questions Patients Ask Most
Is it safe to leave a plate in my arm forever?
Yes for most patients. Titanium and stainless steel plates are designed for lifelong implantation, and orthopedic societies do not recommend routine removal. The exception is a plate causing pain, pressure, or interfering with later surgery.
What percentage of fracture hardware gets removed?
Removal rates vary by country and fracture type, ranging from roughly 5% in some U.S. practices to over 50% in parts of Europe where removal is routine. The variation reflects practice patterns, not medical necessity.
Can I have an MRI with a plate or nail in my body?
Most modern fracture hardware is MRI-conditional, meaning it can be scanned under specific conditions. You need the device model from your operative report so the radiology team can confirm compatibility before scanning.
Does removing the hardware make the bone weaker?
Temporarily, yes. Screw holes leave small voids in bone that fill over weeks to months. Surgeons usually restrict heavy loading for a short period after removal to let those holes remodel.
Will insurance pay for hardware removal?
It depends on the reason. Removal for infection or hardware failure is typically covered as medically necessary. Removal for discomfort or patient preference may be treated as elective, so confirm with your insurer before scheduling.
Can hardware cause pain years after the fracture healed?
It can. Loosening, soft tissue irritation over a prominent plate, and low-grade infection are the common causes. A surgeon can assess whether the implant is the likely source before recommending removal.
What happens if a surgeon can't get a screw out during removal?
Occasionally a seized screw is left in the bone. It's usually harmless, and the surgeon will document it in the operative note so future providers know it's there.
This article is general educational information about orthopedic hardware, not a diagnosis, treatment plan, or medical advice. Decisions about leaving or removing a fixation device should be made with a qualified orthopedic surgeon who can review your imaging, operative report, and symptoms. If you have signs of infection, sudden severe pain, or wound problems around an implant, seek urgent care from a local emergency or clinical service.