The equation 2(x² − 9) + 1 = 1 has exactly two solutions: x = 3 and x = −3. The boundary condition that produces this tidy answer is the constant term on both sides. Because the +1 on the left cancels the 1 on the right, the equation collapses to 2(x² − 9) = 0, and any product equal to zero forces one of its factors to be zero. Since 2 is never zero, the entire problem reduces to x² − 9 = 0, which factors as (x − 3)(x + 3) = 0. Both roots are real, rational, and appear in simplest form with no radicals.
Read the Original Equation Before Touching Either Side
The string "2 left parenthesis x squared minus 9 right parenthesis plus 1 equals 1 2 x 2 −9 1 1" is what you get when a typed equation loses its formatting. Read it as 2(x² − 9) + 1 = 1. The trailing "2 x 2 −9 1 1" is a mangled echo of the same left-hand expression, not a second equation to solve.
Confirm this reading before you solve. The left side has three pieces: a coefficient of 2, a binomial in parentheses, and a constant +1 outside the parentheses. The right side is the single number 1. If your source truly reads 2(x² − 9) + 1 = 12, the problem changes and x = ±√3.5, which is a different answer entirely.
Copy errors are the most common reason students get a "wrong" result on this kind of problem. Retype the equation into a scratch line with explicit multiplication symbols: 2 · (x² − 9) + 1 = 1. If the retyped version matches your source, you have the correct interpretation.
One quick sanity check settles it. Substitute x = 0 into 2(x² − 9) + 1 and you get −17, which is nowhere near 1. That tells you the solution is not near zero and that the parentheses genuinely matter. A solver who drops them and writes 2x² − 9 + 1 = 1 lands on x² = 4.5 and answers x ≈ ±2.12 — a classic distribution error covered later.
Subtract the Same Constant From Both Sides First
Subtracting 1 from both sides is the cleanest first move. It gives 2(x² − 9) = 0. This single line is the pivot of the whole problem, and it takes fewer steps than expanding the parentheses and then re-factoring.
Many students expand immediately: 2x² − 18 + 1 = 1, then 2x² − 17 = 1, then 2x² = 18, then x² = 9. That route reaches the same place, but it involves four arithmetic manipulations instead of one subtraction. Fewer operations mean fewer chances to slip a sign.
The subtraction is legal because of the subtraction property of equality. Whatever you remove from one side, you remove from the other. Written out, the step looks like this: 2(x² − 9) + 1 − 1 = 1 − 1, which simplifies to 2(x² − 9) = 0.
If the right side had been, say, 19, the same move would give 2(x² − 9) = 18 and then x² − 9 = 9, so x² = 18 and x = ±3√2. The method is identical; only the numbers shift. That robustness is why isolating the parenthetical block is worth doing before anything else.
Divide Out the Coefficient of 2 With One Legal Step
Divide both sides by 2 to get x² − 9 = 0. This is the division property of equality in action, and it is valid precisely because 2 is not zero. Division by zero is undefined, so a solver should always note the coefficient is nonzero before dividing it away.
Here is the full state of the equation after each step:
| Step | Operation | Resulting equation |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Write the equation | 2(x² − 9) + 1 = 1 |
| 2 | Subtract 1 from both sides | 2(x² − 9) = 0 |
| 3 | Divide both sides by 2 | x² − 9 = 0 |
| 4 | Factor the difference of squares | (x − 3)(x + 3) = 0 |
| 5 | Apply the zero product property | x − 3 = 0 or x + 3 = 0 |
| 6 | Solve each linear equation | x = 3 or x = −3 |
The table shows that six lines of work finish the problem. No quadratic formula, no completing the square, and no graphing is needed.
The zero product property is doing the heavy lifting at step 5. If a product of two real numbers equals zero, at least one factor must be zero. That is a theorem about real numbers, not a shortcut. It is why factoring is such a powerful finishing move once one side is zero.
Check whether the coefficient could ever be something that changes the answer. If the equation were 0 · (x² − 9) = 0, every real number would solve it, because zero times anything is zero. The coefficient being 2 rules that case out entirely, which is why the division step produces a genuine constraint on x.
Factor x² − 9 as a Difference of Squares, Not Trinomial Guesswork
The expression x² − 9 is a difference of two perfect squares: x² is (x)² and 9 is (3)². The standard identity a² − b² = (a − b)(a + b) applies directly, giving (x − 3)(x + 3) = 0. Recognizing the pattern takes seconds and avoids the trial-and-error of guessing factors of −9 that add to 0.
A trinomial approach also works but is slower here. You would look for two numbers that multiply to −9 and add to 0, and you would eventually land on 3 and −3. The difference-of-squares identity just hands you those numbers.
Expand the factored form to verify it: (x − 3)(x + 3) = x² + 3x − 3x − 9 = x² − 9. The cross terms cancel exactly, which is the signature of a difference of squares. Whenever the middle term vanishes, you are looking at this pattern.
Note the equivalent route through square roots. From x² = 9 you can take the square root of both sides, and the correct statement is x = ±3. The ± symbol matters enormously. Writing only x = 3 discards half the solution set and is the single most frequent error on this type of problem, according to standard algebra instruction at the high school level.
Why the Answer Set Contains Exactly Two Values, Not One
A quadratic equation in one variable has at most two real solutions, and this one achieves that maximum. The two roots, 3 and −3, are distinct real numbers, so the solution set is {−3, 3}. Writing "x = 3" alone is incomplete, and writing "x = ±3" is the compact correct form.
The graph explains why. The function y = 2(x² − 9) + 1 simplifies to y = 2x² − 17, a parabola opening upward with its vertex at (0, −17). The line y = 1 sits 18 units above the vertex, so it crosses the parabola at exactly two points, symmetric about the y-axis. Those crossings occur at x = 3 and x = −3.
Symmetry is built into the equation. Every occurrence of x is squared, so replacing x with −x leaves the equation unchanged. If 3 solves it, −3 must solve it too. This is a useful self-check: any pure quadratic (no x term) has roots that are either both real and opposite in sign, both zero, or a complex conjugate pair.
Check for degenerate cases. If the constant term had been larger than 17 in magnitude in the wrong direction — for instance, 2(x² − 9) + 1 = −20 — the right side would sit below the vertex and there would be no real solutions at all. The number 1 in the original problem places the line above the vertex, guaranteeing two real roots.
Verify Both Roots in the Original Expression in Under a Minute
Substituting each root back into 2(x² − 9) + 1 is the fastest confirmation available, and each check takes two lines of arithmetic. For x = 3: 3² = 9, so 9 − 9 = 0, then 2 · 0 + 1 = 1. The left side equals the right side. For x = −3: (−3)² = 9, so 9 − 9 = 0, then 2 · 0 + 1 = 1. Again it matches.
Squaring a negative number is where verification often goes wrong. A student who writes (−3)² = −9 will conclude the root fails and may discard a correct answer. The rule is that any real number squared is non-negative, so (−3)² = 9. Handled correctly, the check passes.
Verification also catches transcription mistakes early. If you had misread the right side as 12, plugging in x = 3 would give 1, not 12, and the mismatch would flag the error before you committed to x = ±√3.5. Algebra teachers routinely require the check step for exactly this diagnostic reason.
Keep the check cheap. You do not need to re-derive the full simplification, only to evaluate the original left-hand expression at each root and compare with the stated right side. Two evaluations, two comparisons, done.
The Three Mistakes That Break This Problem Most Often
The distribution error leads the list. Writing 2(x² − 9) as 2x² − 9 forgets to multiply the −9 by 2, producing 2x² − 9 + 1 = 1, then 2x² = 9, then x = ±√4.5 ≈ ±2.12. The correct distribution is 2x² − 18, and the missing factor of 2 on the constant is what derails the answer.
Dropping the negative root ranks second. A solver who writes only x = 3 has solved half the problem. Since the equation is quadratic and both roots are real, both belong in the answer, and grading rubrics for this kind of exercise typically award partial credit for one root and full credit only for the complete set.
Misreading the right side ranks third. The garbled string invites a reader to see 12 or some other number where 1 belongs. If the right side really were 12, subtract 1 to get 2(x² − 9) = 11, divide by 2 to get x² − 9 = 5.5, so x² = 14.5 and x = ±√14.5 ≈ ±3.81. Every numeric detail downstream depends on that single digit.
The correction for all three is the same discipline: retype the equation cleanly, perform one operation per line, and substitute both roots back at the end. The check catches the distribution slip, the dropped root surfaces when you count solutions, and the misread constant shows up as a mismatch.
When the Right Side Changes, the Roots Change With It
The method is stable across right-hand values, and running two variants shows how. If the equation is 2(x² − 9) + 1 = 19, subtracting 1 gives 2(x² − 9) = 18, dividing gives x² − 9 = 9, so x² = 18 and x = ±3√2 ≈ ±4.24. The structure of the work is identical to the original problem.
If the equation is 2(x² − 9) + 1 = −17, subtracting 1 gives 2(x² − 9) = −18, dividing gives x² − 9 = −9, so x² = 0 and the only solution is x = 0 (a double root). This is the case where the horizontal line touches the parabola's vertex instead of crossing it.
Push one step further and real solutions disappear. With 2(x² − 9) + 1 = −19, you get 2(x² − 9) = −20, x² − 9 = −10, and x² = −1, which has no real solution because no real number squares to a negative. The answer set is empty over the reals, though complex solutions ±i exist.
These variants are worth practicing because they train you to notice when the equation type shifts. Two real roots, one repeated root, and no real roots are the only three possibilities for a quadratic with real coefficients, and this family of problems walks through all three.
Graph the Left Side to See the Two Crossings
Writing the left side as a function, f(x) = 2(x² − 9) + 1 = 2x² − 17, makes the geometry explicit. The graph is a parabola opening upward, narrower than y = x² because of the coefficient 2, and shifted down 17 units. Its lowest point is the vertex at (0, −17).
The right side, y = 1, is a horizontal line. Solving the equation means finding where the parabola meets that line. The vertical gap between the vertex and the line is 1 − (−17) = 18 units, so the line cuts cleanly through both arms of the parabola at two symmetric points.
Those intersection points are (3, 1) and (−3, 1). Reading the x-coordinates off the graph gives the roots directly. This visual confirmation is why graphing calculators are standard in algebra courses: the picture makes the "two solutions" claim obvious in a way symbols sometimes do not.
The vertex location also predicts the number of solutions without solving. If the line sits above −17, there are two crossings; exactly at −17, one; below, none. For the original equation with right side 1, the line is comfortably above the vertex, so two real roots are guaranteed before any algebra begins.
How to Write the Final Answer in Simplest Form
Simplest form for a quadratic solution set means exact values, fully reduced, with the ± notation where appropriate. For this problem the answer is x = 3 or x = −3, equivalently x = ±3, equivalently the set {−3, 3}. Decimal approximations like 3.0 add nothing and are not simpler.
Order does not matter, but convention often lists the smaller value first or uses the ± shorthand. Both graders and automated systems accept "x = ±3" as complete. Writing "x = 3, x = −3" is equally correct and sometimes clearer for readers unfamiliar with the ± symbol.
If the roots had been irrational, simplest form would mean radical form with the largest perfect square factored out. For the variant x² = 18, the answer is x = ±3√2, not ±√18 and certainly not ±4.24. Simplifying radicals is the last step in those cases, not an optional flourish.
A complete final line for the original problem reads: "The solutions are x = 3 and x = −3." Include the check results if the assignment asks for verification. Anything longer repeats work already shown.
FAQ
Does 2(x² − 9) + 1 = 1 really have two answers?
Yes, it has exactly two real solutions, x = 3 and x = −3. The equation reduces to x² = 9, and a positive number has two real square roots. Students who report one answer usually stopped at the principal root and forgot the ±. A quadratic can never have more than two real roots, so the pair is complete.
What if I read the right side as 12 instead of 1?
Then the solutions become x = ±√14.5, which is roughly ±3.81. Subtract 1 to get 2(x² − 9) = 11, divide by 2 for x² − 9 = 5.5, then add 9 to reach x² = 14.5. Notice how one digit changes the entire answer set, which is why confirming the transcription matters before solving.
Is x = 0 a solution to this equation?
No. Substituting zero gives 2(0 − 9) + 1 = −17, which does not equal 1. Zero would solve only the variant where the right side is −17, since that variant collapses to x² = 0. This difference separates a two-root equation from a double-root one and is a useful edge case to test.
How is this different from solving 2x² − 9 + 1 = 1?
That version drops the parentheses and yields x² = 4.5, so x = ±√4.5 ≈ ±2.12. The correct expanded form is 2x² − 18 + 1, which simplifies to 2x² − 17. The missing factor of 2 on the constant term is the entire source of the discrepancy between the two answers.
Do I need the quadratic formula for this problem?
No. The equation reduces to a form with no linear x term, so factoring or taking square roots finishes it in two lines. The quadratic formula works but involves unnecessary computation with b = 0. Save the formula for equations like x² − 5x + 6 = 0 where factoring the middle term is not immediate.
What does "simplest form" mean for this answer?
It means exact integers with no decimals and no unsimplified radicals. Since both roots are whole numbers, 3 and −3, there is nothing to reduce further. For irrational roots, simplest form would factor the largest perfect square out of the radical, as in ±3√2 rather than ±√18.
Could this equation ever have no real solution?
Yes, if the right side dropped below −17. For example, 2(x² − 9) + 1 = −19 reduces to x² = −1, and no real number squares to a negative value. The threshold is the vertex height: any horizontal line below y = −17 misses the parabola entirely, leaving an empty real solution set.
How do I check my answer quickly on a test?
Substitute each root into the original left-hand expression and compare with the right side. For x = 3, 2(9 − 9) + 1 = 1, and for x = −3, 2(9 − 9) + 1 = 1. Both checks take one line each. If either fails, recheck the sign when squaring and recheck that you distributed the 2 to both terms.